Tom Mison

Ichabod Crane

Nicole Beharie

Abbie Mills

Lyndie Greenwood

Jenny Mills

Orlando Jones

Frank Irving

Katia Winter

Katrina Crane

John Noble

Henry Parrish

John Cho

Andy Brooks

Nestor Serrano

Polygraph Technician

Clancy Brown

Sheriff August Corbin

Nicholas Gonzalez

Detective Luke Morales

Charles Malik Whitfield

Parsons

James Frain

Rutledge

Tongayi Chirisa

Arthur Bernard

Craig Parker

Colonel Tarleton

Neil Jackson

Abraham Van Brunt

Erin Cahill

Lena Gilbert

Laura Spencer

Caroline

Carsten Nørgaard

Hessian

Alex Collins

Thomasson

Tim Holt

Redcoat

Jackson Beals

Mason Guard

Parker Chapin

Crying Boy

Jill Marie Jones

Cynthia Irving

Matt Medrano

Wistaron

Michael Teh

Seamus Duncan

Avis-Marie Barnes

Night Shift Nurse

Angela Bond

Paige Gillespie

Pete Burris

Garrett Gillespie

Amandla Stenberg

Macey Irving

Kathleen York

Ms. Hudson

David Fonteno

Reverend Boland

Nydia McFadden

Possessed Macey

Brennan Brown

Tom - Detective

Louis Herthum

General George Washington

Patrick Gorman

Reverend Alfred Knapp

Victor Garber

Mr. Crane

Derek Mears

Moloch

Chris Walters

Sleepy Hollow Officer #1

Dwayne Boyd

Sleepy Hollow Officer #2

Elaine Nalee

Doctor

Aerli Austen

Waitress

Michael Tourek

Prison Guard

Huntington Daly

Aide

Nat Padgett

Militiaman

Henry Bazemore Jr.

Officer

Claire Bronson

Denise Hemmington

Jason Davis

Jeremy Furth

Monique Ganderton

Serilda

Christy Grantham

Front Desk Nurse

Mary Kraft

Dr. Vega

David Kronawitter

Male Doctor

Alex Livinalli

Wiroh

Carl LeMon

Priest

David Maldonado

Derek (Fireman)

Michelle Rivera Huckaby

EMT

Roxy Olin

Burned Serilda

Frank Roberts

Magistrate

Wes Watson

Kyle

Kevin Cassidy

Armin

Phillip DeVona

Wendel Clark

Lars Gerhard

Hagen

Susan Shalhoub Larkin

Luanne Harley

Patrick Thomas Hogan

Colonial Soldier

Paul Brian Johnson

Forensic Tech

William Neenan

Doxford

D.J. Mifflin

Moloch

Onira Tarés

Grace Dixon

Braden Fitzgerald

Jeremy (12 Years Old)

Danny Rawley

Jeremy (17 Years Old)

Katrina Despain

Isa

Carrie Anne Hunt

Jer

Arin Logan

Nahum

Rya Meyers

Mal

Joe Knezevich

Father Daniel

Michael Roark

Devon Jones

Matt Lintz

Thomas Grey

Miles Doleac

William Grey

Summer Parker

Girl

Dikran Tulaine

Prefect

Marc Fajardo

EMT

Vicki Ellis Gray

Mail Carrier

Robin Dale Robertson

Gov. John White

Kevin Patrick Murphy

Ananias Dare

Becca Potter

Eleanor Dare

Adora Dei

CDC Member

Meg Gillentine

Hazmat Doctor

Sophia Watson

Flower Girl

Joy Glover Walters

Medic

Danielle Sagona

Woman

Lance Tafelski

Hessian Soldier

Craig Trow

Lachlan Fredericks

Anthony K. Hyatt

Sam

Quinten Johnson

Young Butler

Garrett Graham

Corey Weaver

Craig Stark

Chase Weaver

Judd Lormand

Vendor

Gray Hawks

Specialist

Karen Beyer

Woman

Jon W. Sparks

Benjamin Franklin

Mike Whaley

Police Officer

Jimmy Gonzales

Homicide Detective Nuñez

Jahneé Wallace

Teen Abbie

India Scandrick

Teen Jenny

Garrett Kruithof

Colonial Soldier

Richard Cetrone

Headless Horseman (Weapons)

Daniel J. Roberts

Tour Guide

Vince Pisani

Paul Short

Neko Parham

Fuller

Jayson Warner Smith

Carlton

Mark Jeffrey Miller

Jesse Adams

Stephen Shelton

Hessian

Matt Mercurio

Duty Officer

Kenneth Strong

Acolyte of Moloch #3

Bradley Johnson

Acolyte of Moloch #4

Alexander Bryant

Acolyte of Moloch #5

Jim McKeny

George

Déjá Dee

Desk Clerk

John Curran

Oxford Professor

Katie Malia

Faceless Woman

Jason Vail

Latex Man #1

Jeremy Tuttle

Latex Man #2

Marti Matulis

War Horseman

Craig Branham

Headless Horseman (Riding)

Jeremy Owens

Headless Horseman (Weapons)

Allen O'Reilly

Samuel Adams

Paul Burke

Paul Revere

Rae Becka

Mom

Zach Shirey

Son

Erica Page

Chat Lady