Jared Padalecki

Sam Winchester

Jensen Ackles

Dean Winchester

Misha Collins

Castiel

David Haydn-Jones

Arthur Ketch

Mark Pellegrino

Lucifer

DJ Qualls

Garth Fitzgerald

Emily Perkins

Becky Rosen

Alison Araya

Vice Principal Bailey

Burkely Duffield

Billy Whitman

Melanie Merkosky

Carla

Lane Davies

Francis Tumblety

Anne Marie DeLuise

Janet Whitman

Shoshannah Stern

Eileen Leahy

Danneel Ackles

Sister Jo / Anael

Andrew Airlie

Henry Whitman

Luke Camilleri

Josh May

Keegan Connor Tracy

Mother Witch

Jodelle Ferland

Emily

Jennifer Spence

Melly Krokowski

Jovanna Huguet

Bloody Mary / Mary Worthington

Keith Szarabajka

Donatello Redfield / God

Christian Kane

Lee Webb

Sean Tyson

Clown Ghost

Anna Grace Barlow

Ashley Monroe / Lilith

Peter Skagen

Sheriff

Vladimir Ruzich

Hitman

Sharon Taylor

Ardat

Steven Allerick

Cal

Mellany Barros

Veronica

Rachel Hayward

Sheriff Dignan

Markian Tarasiuk

Andy May

Art Kitching

Sheriff Alden Roy

Alex Sturman

Jacinda

Sean Quan

Caleb Krokowski

Emy Aneke

Sheriff Dillon

Aliyah O'Brien

Lorna

Luvia Petersen

Sue Barrish

Tom Stevens

Leviathan

Sarah Smyth

Bess Fitzgerald

Danny Dworkis

Cutty

Emma Oliver

Gertie Fitzgerald

William Brody

Castiel Fitzgerald

Austin Brody

Sam Fitzgerald

Christian Lagasse

Teddy

Jesse Hutch

Brad

Daryl Ducharme

Maul

Jacob Machin

Store Clerk Ted

Joe Allard

Announcer

Lynda Boyd

Moira / Fortuna

Hanneke Talbot

Evie

Brent Stait

Pool Hall Player

Stephen Huszar

Pax

Jason Burkart

Vikings Fan

Ashley Roxburgh

Waitress

Harry Rob Bruner

Leonard

Ryan Hesp

Kabriel

Lalo Espejo

Joey Six

Kahlil Ashanti

Sheriff Evans

Sandra Ferens

Merle

Nicco Del Rio

Radio Shed Clerk

Amy Waugh

Radio Shed Customer

William Vaughan

Demon

David Lyle

Man with a Broken Foot

Amélie Eve

A Girl in the Garden

Adam Beauchesne

Zack

Mark Dozlaw

Conner Todd

Bernadette Beck

Gwen

Kelsey Crane

Caitlin Johnson

Robert Wisdom

Uriel

Genevieve Padalecki

Ruby

Dimitri Vantis

Sergei

Amanda Spinosa

Rachel's Friend

Jasmine Miriguay

Rachel

Isabella Barr

Carla's Daughter

Kyle Strauts

Cadaverous Ghost

Alexander Calvert

Nevin Burkholder

Malfayan

Shanae Tomasevich

Woman in White

Donna Soares

Nurse

Jay Hindle

Roy

Jillian Knowles

Tori Taylor

Jesse Franchuk

Bunker Demon

Andrew J. Hampton

Male Nurse

Emma Cam

Julie

Sebastian Kroon

Andy

Jasmine Lukuku

Receptionist

Madelyn Grace

Angela Sullivan

Georgia Bradner

Sally Anderson

Ryan Elm

Bar Brawler #1

Brad Kelly

Bar Brawler #2

Ty Olsson

Eli / Benny Lafitte

Meagen Fay

Mrs. Butters

Kavan Smith

Cuthbert Sinclair

Charlie Kerr

Vampire #1

Alden Doyle

Vampire #2

Skyler Mowatt

Thule Officer

Emily Swallow

Amara

Steve Bacic

Pastor Joe

Ruth Connell

Rowena MacLeod

Nicole Muñoz

Sylvia

Spencer Borgeson

Dean Winchester II (Adult)

Sara Southey

Valerie Jones

Brady Droulis

Dean Winchester II (Young)

Felicia Day

Charlie Bradbury

Rachel Miner

Meg Masters

Meghan Drew

Valerie's Friend

Beckham Skodje

Dean Winchester II (Toddler)

Kim Rhodes

Jody Mills

Thabo Ketshabetswe

Mitch

Rob Benedict

God

Katherine Ramdeen

Alex Jones

Yadira Guevara-Prip

Kaia Nieves

Wonita Joy

Center Worker

Beatrice Zeilinger

Sheriff Adams

Christian Michael Cooper

Young Sam Winchester

Jim Beaver

Bobby Singer

Paxton Singleton

Young Dean Winchester

Jake Abel

Adam Milligan / Michael

Elle McKinnon

Young Caitlin Johnson

Lisa Berry

Billie

Liam Hughes

Young Travis Johnson

Ryan Alexander McDonald

Travis Johnson

Cecilly Day

Waitress

Alessandro Juliani

Adam

Carmen Moore

Serafina

Corina Bizim

Admiring Female Angel

Christopher Webb

Admiring Male Angel

Eileen Barnett

Talli / Crystal

Duncan Bourke

Spa Attendant

Jeff Gladstone

Reaper

Briana Buckmaster

Donna Hanscum

Max Boateng

Warding Reaper

Kimberley Sustad

Betty

Ava Grace Cooper

Lily

Kerensa Cooper

Dana

Christine Chatelain

Jenny

Max Montesi

Vampire

Catherine Lough Haggquist

Jules

Tori Katongo

Stevie

Jillian Walchuck

Lily and Dana's Mom

Sean Poague

Lily and Dana's Dad

Wolsey Brooks

Wounded Refugee Hunter

Warren Abbott

Spencer

Berkeley Ratzlaff

Susie Martin