Kayvan Novak

Nandor the Relentless

Matt Berry

Laszlo Cravensworth

Natasia Demetriou

Nadja

Harvey Guillén

Guillermo de la Cruz

Mark Proksch

Colin Robinson / Baby Colin

Kristen Schaal

Floating Woman / The Guide

Jamison Webb

Park Man

Kate Comer

Park Woman

Warren Barrow

Cashier

Casey Feigh

Game Master

Chris Perfetti

Kyle

Hayden Szeto

Jonathan

Marceline Hugot

Barbara Lazarro

Richie Moriarty

Doug Peterson

KhaRå Martin

Cheyenne

Alison Niven

Larper #1

Faith Curnew

Larper #2

Mary Pitt

Ms. Oakley

Jon Gabrus

Wharfinger

Vanessa Bayer

Evie Russell

Arj Barker

Werewolf Leader

Michael Man

Dan

Viviana Zarrillo

Kashana

Dominic Cuzzocrea

Arnie

Rob Ramsay

Biff

Kelly Penner

Preppy Werewolf

Hannan Younis

Ange Werewolf

Ro Manning

Dougie Werewolf

Justin Bigelli

Toby Werewolf

Bobby Wilson

Marcus Werewolf

Barbara de la Fuente

Rhonda

Kevin Finn

Waiter

Bobby Daniels

Staten Island Guy

Torin Arsenault

Love-Up Guy

Mary Gillis

June

Khadijah Roberts-Abdullah

Paramedic #1

Byron Abalos

Paramedic #2

Jeremy O. Harris

Colby

Ariane Laezza

Bridge & Tunnel Vampire

Kip Brown

Bouncer

Alex Karzis

Creepy Vampire

Nalini Ingrita

Child Vampire #1

Aaron Davis

Child Vampire #2

Craig Burnatowski

The Silent One

Craig Henry

Vampire DJ

Siobhan Fallon Hogan

Karen

Jessica B. Hill

Phil's Girlfriend

Justin Linville

Bobby

Ted Hallett

Dude #1

Alex Spencer

Police Officer

James Roussel

Horse Cop

Tilda Swinton

Tilda

Jonny Brugh

Deacon Brucke

Danny Trejo

Danny

Paul Reubens

Paul

Wesley Snipes

Wesley

Dave Bautista

Garrett the Vampire

Gloria Laino

Baron's Familiar

Rashaana Cumberbatch

Other Familiar #1

Alexandra Henrikson

Vasilika the Defiler

Francis Melling

Other Familiar #2

Pamela MacDonald

Older Familiar

Chick Roberts

Even Older Familiar

Ejyp Johnson

The Dreaded Fayard

Beanie Feldstein

Jenna

Maury Ginsberg

Immigration Officer

Chantale Renee

Lecturer

Emily Stranges

Other Student

Adrian Spencer

Jocky Dude

Dave Murgittroyd

Ska Dude

Luis Fernandes

Man on Street

Eric Andrews

Phil

James Dwyer

Jeremy

Paige Locke

90s Blonde

Michael Giel

Constantine

Victoria Whistance-Smith

Flapper

Julia Vally

Dominatrix

Alessandra Vite

Store Employee

Kevin Chiao

Cater Waiter

Sean Kavanaugh

Vampire in Leather Costume

Redd Ochoa

Jiang Shi

Samantha Madely

Sylvia

Francesco Antonio

Babadook

Becky Johnson

Vampire #1

Julie Mahendran

Vampire #2

Jean Edwards

Madelaine

Oliver Dennis

Priest

Karim Butt

Teen #1

Max Calinescu

Teen #2

Jake McDorman

Jeff Suckler

Veronika Slowikowska

Shanice

Nick Kroll

Simon the Devious

Michael Dara

Count Rapula

Jemaine Clement

Vladislav the Poker

Sash Striga

Vampire Counsel Member (uncredited)

Evan Rachel Wood

Evan

Taika Waititi

Viago Von Dorna Schmarten Scheden Heimburg

Doug Jones

Baron Afanas

Anthony Atamanuik

Sean Rinaldi

Christina Pitts Jazzar

Dancer