Nine months after Henry Parrish and Katrina Crane's demise, Abbie Mills receives a message from Ichabod Crane after not hearing from him for several months. They now become aware of a new evil that must be addressed, and join forces with old friends, and new allies to face this new threat to Sleepy Hollow - a mysterious woman named Pandora.
Cast
Tom Mison
Ichabod Crane
Nicole Beharie
Abbie Mills
Lyndie Greenwood
Jenny Mills
Nikki Reed
Betsy Ross
Zach Appelman
Joe Corbin
Lance Gross
Daniel Reynolds
Shannyn Sossamon
Pandora
Clancy Brown
Sheriff August Corbin
Emily Deschanel
Dr. Temperance Brennan
David Boreanaz
FBI Special Agent Seeley Booth
Chris Bert
Nelson Meyers
Jeremy Owens
Headless Horseman
Robin Strasds
Daniel Boone
C. Thomas Howell
SAC Mick Granger
James Chen
Lorenzo Chang
Onira Tarés
Grace Dixon
Craig Branham
Headless Horseman (Riding)
Cristian Gonzalez
SWAT Commander
Joshua Hoover
Host
Kenneth Israel
Police Officer
Zero Kazama
Johnny Ong
Benjamin Keepers
Brent
Rob Lawhon
Todd
John Paul Marston
Colonel Prescott
Maya Kazan
Zoe Corinth
Jessica Camacho
Agent Sophie Foster
Andy Pessoa
Young Ichabod
Alana Cavanaugh
Saffron Paynter
Bill Irwin
Atticus Nevins
Mark Campbell
Gen. George Washington
Michael Pemberton
Judge Chrysdale
Peter Mensah
The Hidden One
Michael O'Keefe
Director Jack Walters
Katie Malia
Onryo
James McDaniel
Ezra Mills
Derek Mears
The Kindred
Charles Aitken
Dr. Japeth Leeds / The Jersey Devil
Marti Matulis
Yao-Quai
Cullen Moss
ICE Officer
Timothy Douglas Perez
Jesus
Alexander Ward
Marcus Collins / The Whispering Wraith
Charlene Amoia
Susan James
Viviana Chavez
Kit Nicora
Nicholas Guest
General William Howe
Ethan Henry
Paul Everett
Lindsay Ayliffe
Stephens
Ryan Brink
Bertie
Perry Cox
Student
Autumn Dial
Emily Kates
James Donadio
Professor
Julia Armitage
Alice
Katie Cofield
Teacher
Lawton Denis
Gregory Gonda
Elyse Dufour
Babysitter
Cynthia Evans
Max's Wife
Makabe Ganey
Betsy's Nephew
Brooklyn Garmon
Tessa Paynter
Joe Hardy Jr.
Max Paynter
Samantha Ann
Abyzou
Myles Lawsin
Child
Chace Beck
Man
Chris Gann
Van Driver
Tia Hendricks
April's Mother
Elyn Jaime
April
Corey Reitz
Teen Devil
Stephen Ruffin
Teen Dracula
Michael Sokol
Bald Zombie
Codi Waugh
Teen Angel
Bethany Levy
The Soucouyant
Tony Pham
Teppanyaki Chef
Tyler Webster
Surly Teenager
Kendrick Cross
Crane's Lawyer
Lynne Ashe
Brenda (Bailiff)
Adena Brumer
Federal Prosecutor
Catherine Copplestone
PTA President
Rotimi Paul
Azzaca
Jose Miguel Vasquez
Agent Ramirez
Bret McKee
Hessian Soldier #1
Robert Hendren
Hessian Soldier #2
Richard Kohberger
Johnny Revere
Griffin Freeman
Nathan Hale
Randy Havens
Patrick McKenna
Yolanda Asher
Secretary
Matthew Luret
Marquis de Lafayette
Diesel Madkins
Restoration Driver
Michael Perry
Restoration Worker #1
Jeremy Harrison
Restoration Worker #3
Heighlen Boyd
Krissy Kowalick
Winkie Browning
Wealthy Wife
Jimmy Ray Pickens
Wealthy Husband
Vince Foster
FBI Agent
Zechariah Pierce
Doug Frank
Mike Stoudt
Stagehand
Morgan Ayres
Young Corbin
Drew Matthews
Young Nevins
Alan Boell
Sleepy Hollow Officer
Nelson Bonilla
Vincent
Benny Demus
Gary
Dylan Nunez
Webb
Byron Baudo
Village Elder
Robbie Cox
Thomas Dampier
Tyler Cravens
Dr. Peter Cranston
Jason Looney
Robbie Malone
Stephen Shane Martin
Christopher Dampier
Roy McCrerey
Hans Christensen
Victor Turner
Blake
Mark Ashworth
Connor Dunne
Gary Lil' G Jenkins
Guitarist
Matt Lewis
Drummer
Christian Walker
Bassist
C.C. Ice
Banshee
Brad Ashten
Francis Scott Key
Edward McCreary
Young Soldier
Daniel Norris
Eternal Soldier
Geoffrey Williams
Docent
Sir Brodie
Priest
Shay Mack
Church Woman Who Screams
Katie Fryburger
Church Member #1 Child
Morgan Brown
Church Member #3
Lundyn Ransom
Choir Member #1
Karen Battiste
Choir Member #2
Bridget Carrington
Choir Member #3
Janeen Michael
Choir Member #4
Vashti Denise Powell
Choir Member #5
Dustin Lewis
Paul Revere
Sara Rudeseal
Betsy's Niece
Marco Schittone
David
Brittany Wilkerson
Gregory's Mom
Naida Nelson
FBI Agent
Sarah Borne
Girl Who Gets Doused With Beer
Tyshon Freeman
Bruiser Frat Guy
Jeremy Madden
Excited Frat Guy
Colton Medlin
Burly Frat Guy
Walker Stipe
Burly Toga-Wearing Frat Guy Who Pukes
Anthony K. Hyatt
Randall Martin
Juan Pablo Veizaga
Richard Williams
Paul Brian Johnson
Detective Rudi Chandler
Jon Kohler
Sammy
Angela Ray
Clerk
Cody Robinson
Eton Prefect
Mykee Selkin
Fist Bump Guy
Nick Stanner
Ripper
Alex Sgambati
Dani
Josh Ventura
Matt Gorman
Katia Winter
Katrina Crane (archive footage) (uncredited)
Neil Jackson
Abraham Van Brunt (archive footage) (uncredited)
Episodes
I, Witness
With old enemies gone, Abbie and Crane are apparently moving on with their lives. However, the discovery of a mysterious tablet shows that there may be a new dark prophecy surrounding our Witnesses. The two team together, with the help of an old amulet, and continue their epic takedown of the forces of evil.
Whispers in the Dark
When Pandora uses her powers to unleash a new form of evil, Abbie and Crane are forced to face their pasts in unexpected ways.
Blood and Fear
Fear is rampant in Sleepy Hollow when Pandora releases an ancient artifact from her box that can transform an ordinary human into a terrifying figure from the past.
The Sisters Mills
More powerful than ever, Pandora unleashes her most evil force yet. Meanwhile, Abbie and Jenny work together when the latest monster targets the children of Sleepy Hollow.
Dead Men Tell No Tales (II)
With Booth and Brennan in tow, Abbie and Crane set out to prove that supernatural forces are at play when a mysterious death plagues the FBI. As Pandora unleashes a force to awaken the dangerous Red Coast General Howe, both teams must find a way to save the town from the British Army of the Undead. Can the power of Booth and Brennan combined with Abbie and Crane be enough to stop Pandora’s evil forces? The crossover starts on Bones S11E05 The Resurrection in the Remains (I).
This Red Lady from Caribee
When Pandora unleashes an iconic monster to haunt the residents of Sleepy Hollow as they sleep, Abbie and Jenny are tempted to confront a painful part of their past. Meanwhile, Abbie makes a crucial decision for her career and Crane does his best to guide her with wisdom from his own experiences. Will Ichabod lead Abbie to the right decision?
The Art of War
When Reynolds heads to D.C. to discuss developments in the Nevins case, Abbie is left in command. Jenny and Joe deal with unexpected consequences as a result of stealing the shard, which leaves both the lives of the heroes and Abbie's career in great peril. Meanwhile, a new, more dangerous evil force is revealed.
Novus Ordo Seclorum
In the aftermath of Jenny and Joe's run-in with Sophie, Abbie is in deep water with Reynolds. Meanwhile, the Witnesses deal with lasting implications of the shard and find themselves in grave danger as they come face-to-face with a greater evil than they could have imagined.
One Life
Following Abbie's huge sacrifice, Crane and Jennie find themselves at a loss. In an effort to save Abbie, Crane forms and unlikely partnership and Jenny confronts a former foe.
Incident At Stone Manor
In the quest to save Abbie, Crane and Sophie are forced to battle a supernatural force targeting the citizens of Sleepy Hollow, while Pandora and The Hidden One only grow stronger. Meanwhile, in an effort to find out what truly happened to her sister, Jenny faces an old foe: her father. Can our heroes solve their most personal case yet?
Kindred Spirits
The Kindred, the Frankenstein-esque creature Abby & Crane used against the Headless Horseman, returns and wreaks bloody havoc on Sleepy Hollow.
Sins of the Father
When Jenny makes the decision to confront her father, family turmoil from the past rises to the surface. Meanwhile, Atticus Nevins returns to town, bringing more danger than the FBI could have imagined.
Dark Mirror
Ichabod discovers that the creature that inspired the stories of the Jersey Devil. Meanwhile, Joe and Jenny reach a possible hurdle in their relationship.
Into the Wild
On an FBI team-building day, Abbie and Sophie come face to face with a monster that may finally blow their cover with Reynolds. Meanwhile, Jenny and Joe find themselves in possession of something precious and Crane discovers that the symbol from the Catacombs may be more important than he realized.
Incommunicado
After a supernatural event takes the Witnesses by surprise, both Crane and Abbie are forced to work alongside their most hated foes yet. Meanwhile, Jenny and Joe struggle to salvage their relationship, as they continue to battle their own internal demons.
Dawn's Early Light
As The Hidden One grows stronger, Crane must examine his past with Betsy Ross to find the key to stopping him. Meanwhile, Jenny wonders if she can ever have a relationship with her father, and Abbie faces a hard decision as things with Reynolds become more strained.
Delaware
With a single day left before The Hidden One regains omniscience, Abbie and Crane must do the unthinkable in a last-ditch effort to save the world. Meanwhile, Jenny, Joe and Sophie devise a plan to stall as the Witnesses work.
Ragnarok
After a startling discovery, Abbie and Crane realize what they must do in order to make Pandora’s box complete again. Meanwhile, the team works tirelessly to stop The Hidden One, before he destroys all of humanity. Can the Witnesses succeed with the fate of the world in their hands once again.
Sleepy Hollow Ratings
Overall
Overall rating of the media
Scares
How effective are the jump scares
Atmosphere
How immersive and tense is the atmosphere
Gore
Level and quality of gore/violence
Story
Quality of the storyline and plot
Special Effects
Quality of special/visual effects
Character Development
Depth and growth of characters
Pacing
Flow and timing of the narrative