Cast
Javier Bardem
José Menendez
Chloë Sevigny
Mary Louise 'Kitty' Menendez
Cooper Koch
Erik Menendez
Nicholas Alexander Chavez
Lyle Menendez
Dallas Roberts
Dr. Jerome Oziel
Jason Butler Harner
Det. Les Zoeller
Leslie Grossman
Judalon Smyth
Jeff Perry
Peter Hoffman
Marlene Forte
Marta Cano
Jade Pettyjohn
Jamie Pisarcik
Tanner Stine
Perry Berman
Ethan Bell
Cowboy (Trick-or-Treater)
Kamy D. Bruder
Chauffeur
Mara Casey
Marzi Eisenberg
Jaja Corral
Yoda (Trick-or-Treater)
Max Hawksford
Coach
Grayson Thorne Kilpatrick
Half-Assed Zombie (Trick-or-Treater)
Lorraine Lerner
Gun Store Clerk
Jack Perry
Umpire
Jake Reiner
KTLA Reporter
Tracey Silver
Mrs. Hoffman
Sarah Summers
Big 5 Clerk
Leanne Suter
CBS 2 Reporter
Ashley Sutton
Wine Rep
Jim Cody Williams
Old Man
Enrique Murciano
Carlos Baralt
Larry Clarke
Brian Andersen
Drew Powell
Det. Tom Linehan
Charlie Hall
Craig Cignarelli
Rick Holmes
Randolph Wright
Ron Bottitta
Chief Marvin Iannone
Walter Belenky
Officer Czarnocki
Christopher Christian
BHPD Officer
Justin Cuomo
Motorcycle Cop
Johnny D'Esposito
Gang Member
Anthony Elfonzia
Locksmith
Andy Fitzgerald
Mark Heffernan
Brittany Freeth
Uniformed Officer
Gregory Gast
Coroner
Peter A. Hulne
Sergeant West
Jason Jia
Cop
Don O. Knowlton
Dan Stanton
Gisela Kovach
Zsa Zsa Gabor
Isabella Rose Landau
Oziel's Daughter
Shelby Lee
AMC Girl (archive footage)
Vanessa Lua
Flor
Ryan Maltz
Billy Wright
Artie O'Daly
Officer Mo Angel
Emory Ogletree II
Weight Coach
Donovan Patton
Officer Butkus
Jamie Tompkins
Real Estate Agent
Alex Vaughan
Philip
Gareth Williams
Det. Edmonds
Clara York
Klara Wright
Ari Graynor
Leslie Abramson
Nathan Lane
Dominick Dunne
Michael Gladis
Tim Rutten
Gil Ozeri
Dr. William Vicary
Salvator Xuereb
Robert Shapiro
Brandon Santana
Tony
Tessa Auberjonois
Dr. Laurel Oziel
Blanca Araceli
Grandma Maria
Robert Sean Burke
Cop #2
Mario Cortez
Cop #1
Brad Culver
Gerald Chaleff
Earlene Davis
Sharon
Rhied De Castro
Arnel Salvatierra
Jake Elliott
Hayden Rodgers
Jacob Figueroa
Edwards
Stephen Friedrich
Young Reporter
Roni Geva
Adoption Agent
Nathen Gurrola
Andy Cano
Layne Herrin
Glenn Stevens
Kristin Lindquist
Joyce
Chloe Oloren
Noelle
Arthur Richardson
Guy
Rebecca Safier
Realtor
Labrandon Shead
Miller
Jess Weixler
Jill Lansing
Anthony Turpel
Donovan Goodreau
Catherine Carlen
Wealthy Socialite
Joe Chambrello
Handsome Actor
Paul Chirico
Other Police Officer
Joseph Culp
Boat Captain
Robert Dill
Police Officer
Bradley Fisher
Movie Executive
Dylan Friedman
13 y/o Lyle
Kevin Gardner
Clerk
Nicole Ghastin
Proctor
Bernadette Guckin
Gun Range Worker
Steve Hasley
Other Employee
Lauren Lopez
Famous Actress
Valerie Perri
Barbara
Jeremy W. Roberts
Employee
Jagger Rodriguez
7 y/o Lyle
Stone Rooke
5 y/o Erik
Juliet Rusche
Diane Vandermolen
Orlando Pineda
Young José Menendez
Belle Shouse
Young Kitty Menendez
Hugo Medina
Edgardo Diaz
Guilford Adams
Accountant
Sally Brooks
Lula Mae
John Colton
Justice of the Peace
Matthew Gilmore
Photographer
John Gloria
Contractor
Jennifer Ingrum
Louise
Julian Larach
Hustler
Mandy Levin
Dr. Anne Heller
Rob Mainord
Dr. Alan Fox
Brooke McCormick
Woman
Jeff Pride
Det. Mills
Tom Simmons
Dean of Students
Milana Vayntrub
Pam Bozanich
Melissa Bailey
Juror #8
Dylan Barton
Griffin Dunne
Will Block
Alex Dunne
Andrea Cañizares-Fernandez
Juror #4
John Churchill
George
Helen Duffy
Clerk
Peggy Dunne
Juror #5
Natalie Taylor Gray
Norma Novelli
David Lee Hess
Billy
Matt Kaminsky
Sweeney's Attorney
Mark Kelly
Norton
Joyce King
Juror #10
Amie MacKenzie
Linda
Ross Mackenzie
Judge Weisberg
Miguel Pérez
Peter Cano
Shaw Purnell
Ellen 'Lenny' Dunne
Alex Rollins
Paul D'Emilio
Amy Schloerb
Velma Smith
Luke Matthew Simon
Cousin Al
Edward Singletary
Judge Burton Katz
Neil Vincent Smith
John Thomas Sweeney
Zabeth Russell
Juror #1
Ruben Vernier
Brian Eslaminia
Jett Wilder
Dominique Dunne
O'Neil Cespedes
Willie
Tanya Clarke
Carrie
Erin Coker
Doctor
Christine Corpuz
Nurse
Adam Dunnells
Inmate
Vince Duvall
Joe
Johnny James Fiore
Other Inmate
Sarah Garofalo
Cousin Diane
Trae Ireland
OJ Simpson
Jordan Matlock
Coach Wadlington
Paul Adelstein
David Conn
Patrick Breen
Alternate Juror
Vicki Lawrence
Leigh
Cinda Adams
Court Clerk (Menendez Trial)
Catherine Adell
Reporter #2
Tom Beyer
Robbie
Stephen Bralver
Driver (Erik's Van)
Andy Forrest
Charles Gessler
Jim Grollman
Grant Walker
Victor Gonzalez
Scary Prisoner
Joshua Hoover
Andrew
Desiree Mee Jung
Reporter #1
Diane Yang
Mary
Heather Knobel
Carol Najera
Anastasia Leddick
Lesley
Jamison McDermott
Anna Eriksson
Yvonne Miranda
Newscaster
Neiko Neal
Guard (Anteroom)
Andrew Oliveri
Barry Levin
Reece Rios
Phil
Erik Rozet
Guard #3
Stephen W. Schriver
Driver (Lyle's Van)
Sam Skolnik
Isaac
Christian Telesmar
Alfa Romeo Driver
Juan Francisco Villa
Fr. Viera
Gina Vitori
Gina
Jason Wayne Wong
Reporter #3
Vincent Duvall
Joe
Episodes
Blame It on the Rain
Plagued by dark thoughts after the murders, Erik opens up to his therapist and shares disturbing details that put the doctor in a difficult position.
Spree
After throwing suspicion elsewhere during police questioning, Lyle and Erik go on a wild spending spree while waiting for Jose's will to be read.
Brother, Can You Spare a Dime?
The brothers navigate life behind bars after police receive a tip-off about the tapes. A new defense attorney prompts Erik to talk about the past.
Kill or Be Killed
Lyle shares painful memories of trying to live up to his father's expectations, detailing the timeline and impact of Jose's abuse and its effect on Erik.
The Hurt Man
During an emotional conversation with Leslie, Erik gives a harrowing account of the sexual abuse and torture he experienced throughout his childhood.
Don't Dream It's Over
The trajectory of Jose and Kitty's relationship — from their courtship through their fracturing marriage — plays out against family therapy sessions.
Showtime
Lyle and Erik struggle to shape their defense before the trial. Then Menendez mania hits — from cheering crowds to fan mail and courtroom TV cameras.
Seismic Shifts
A captivating witness alters courtroom dynamics, and Erik's testimony causes a sibling rift. The Menendez pop-culture moment begins to fade.
Hang Men
At a second trial, the prosecution aims to prove that Erik and Lyle are cold-blooded killers. After the verdict, the brothers face a new reality.
Monsters Ratings
Overall
Overall rating of the media
Scares
How effective are the jump scares
Atmosphere
How immersive and tense is the atmosphere
Gore
Level and quality of gore/violence
Story
Quality of the storyline and plot
Special Effects
Quality of special/visual effects
Character Development
Depth and growth of characters
Pacing
Flow and timing of the narrative