Jason Ralph

Quentin Coldwater

Olivia Taylor Dudley

Alice Quinn

Arjun Gupta

William "Penny" Adiyodi

Stella Maeve

Julia Wicker

Jade Tailor

Kady Orloff-Diaz

Hale Appleman

Eliot Waugh

Summer Bishil

Margo Hanson

Trevor Einhorn

Josh Hoberman

Rick Worthy

Dean Fogg

Brittany Curran

Fen

Esmé Bianco

Eliza

Rose Liston

Jane Chatwin

Abby Miller

Emily Greenstreet

Tom Amandes

Daniel Quinn

Garcelle Beauvais

Our Lady Underground

Arlen Escarpeta

Prince Ess

Faran Tahir

The Great Cock of the Darkling Woods

Roger Cross

Admiral Lacker

Julian Richings

Asteroth

Markian Tarasiuk

Prince Micah

Robert Corness

Puzzler

David James Lewis

Dr. Walton

Stephanie Nogueras

Young Harriet

Bola Omodara

Zan

Sean Owen Roberts

Brooklyn Vampire

Aaron Paul Stewart

Rambo

Wolsey Brooks

Palace Guard

Haig Sutherland

Father Poe

Alex Duncan

Shara

Robert Rozen

Cal

Andres Joseph

Donovan

Celia Reid

Maggie

Mik Byskov

Naru

Patrick Sabongui

Bingle

Justin Turnbull

Construction Worker

Daniella Alonso

Pirate King

Zahf Paroo

Gillen

Kate Robbins

Carol

Nikolai Witschl

Ominous Fairy

Jason Simpson

Hoop

Madeleine Arthur

Fray

Mitch Ainley

Lance Morrison

Michael Kopsa

Emmett Morrison

Michael Ryan

Eliot's Father

Arthur MacKinnon

Rupert Chatwin

Matt Afonso

Bodi

Jason Vaisvila

Shep

Kylee Bush

Arielle

Darien Martin

Lunk

Latonya Williams

Handmaid

Sebastian Billingsley-Rodriguez

Rupert - Age 5

Tim Donadt

Rupert - Age 20

Harvey Guillén

Benedict Pickwick

Nicholas Coombe

Prince Fomar

Benjamin Wilkinson

The Incubus

Dustin Ingram

Hyman Cooper

Sera Gamble

Water Dragon (voice)

Birkett Turton

Vince

Mackenzie Murdock

Orderly

Hannah Levien

Victoria

Roan Curtis

Sylvia

Anja Savcic

Skye

William Vaughan

Underworld Park Ranger

Melanie Chan

Maribel

Chris Britton

Demon Todd

Mackenzie Astin

Richard

Spencer Garrett

Ted Coldwater

Mike Moore

Bunny (voice)

Candis Cayne

Fairy Queen

Jaime Ray Newman

Irene McAllistair

Michaela McManus

Callie

Alexandra Metz

Ora

Spencer Daniels

Nameless

Miranda Edwards

Heloise

Sergio Osuna

Rafe

Georgie Daburas

Prometheus

Keegan Connor Tracy

Professor Lipson

Dina Meyer

Stone Queen

Ryan McDonald

Bacchus

Madisen Beaty

Iris

Mageina Tovah

The Librarian

Felicia Day

Poppy

Judith Hoag

Stephanie Quinn

Daniel Nemes

Gavin

Marlee Matlin

Harriet

Kacey Rohl

Marina Andrieski

Adam DiMarco

Todd

Rizwan Manji

Tick Pickwick

Cassandra Naud

Partier #5 (uncredited)