Emily Ruth Verona's Midnight on Beacon Street
Released on 08/20/2025
This week Kelly and Katai read MIDNIGHT ON BEACON STREET by Emily Ruth Verona, a clever take on the Teen Creeps slasher genre that had them cheering. They talk loving the book, hating Gabby of Goodreads, beautiful inner turmoil, a textbook example of surprising but inevitable, what they’ve been watching/playing, and more!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Caroline B. Cooney's Goddess of Yesterday
Released on 08/13/2025
This week Kelly and Katai read The Goddess of Yesterday by Caroline B. Cooney, an outstanding take on Greek historical myth set around the beginning of the Trojan War. They talk loving Anaxandra, hating Paris and Helen, whether quicksilver is mercury, and more!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Mary Downing Hahn's The Old Willis Place
Released on 07/30/2025
This week Kelly and Katai read THE OLD WILLIS PLACE by Mary Downing Hahn, a beautiful story of tragic ghost children and the nice dum dum who thinks they’re just in a cult. They talk forgiveness, feeling like Miss Willis has at least 60 more years of penance, feeling for Diana and Georgie, being whatever about Lissa, and more.
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Kay Chronister's The Bog Wife
Released on 07/23/2025
This week Kelly and Katai read THE BOG WIFE by Kay Chronister, a moving story of family and bogs. They talk great prose, beautifully realized characters, the failings of modern American online therapizing, family trauma, magical realism, and bogs bogs bogs.
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
R.L. Stine's Party Games
Released on 07/16/2025
This week Kelly and Katai read the 2014 FEAR STREET reboot entry PARTY GAMES by R.L. Stine, the story of a dum dum who gets a crush on a Fear boy and misses every red flag during his birthday death games. They talk psycho boys, poorly designed murder games, going to bed smelling of burger, missed villain opportunities, unimpressive party spreads, and more!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Patreon Preview: Emma Cline's THE GIRLS
Released on 07/09/2025
Sicknesses and work/shooting schedules and life had us unable to record this week, so here's an Outside Genre episode from our Patreon!
Kelly and Katai talk THE GIRLS by Emma Cline, a beautiful rumination on girlhood, acquiescence, AND VIOLENT NORCAL CULTS! Thank you so much to listener Jenna Jardin for the book suggestion! The irresistible pull of someone with power, the desire to be desired, and how everyone just wants, wants, wants.
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Lurlene McDaniels's Angels Watching Over Me
Released on 07/02/2025
This week Kelly and Katai dived into ANGELS WATCHING OVER ME, the first entry in Lurlene McDaniels' Angels Trilogy--and they will not be returning! They talk exoticizing and eroticizing the Amish, some Belle Gibson ass cancer messaging, confusing angel messaging, how they'd have talked shit on Leah as her fellow patients, and more!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
R.L. Stine's Don't Stay Up Late
Released on 06/25/2025
This week Kelly and Katai read DON'T STAY UP LATE (A FEAR STREET NOVEL) by R.L. Stine, the story of a girl whose dad dies and then she almost gets gaslit to death. They talk the return of the angel faced white blonde haired boy charge, moms who need to get different jobs, absolutely bonkers monster child conspiracies, nary an endgame to be found, and more!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Beverly Butler's Ghost Cat
Released on 06/18/2025
This week on the podcast Kelly and Katai read GHOST CAT by Beverly Butler. They talk death by coddling, hating Todd, loving Annabel, hating Todd, mixing wisdom with fury, hating Todd, and also hating Todd!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
R.L. Stine's Fear Street Nights Trilogy: Moonlight Secrets, Midnight Games, & Darkest Dawn
Released on 06/11/2025
This week on the podcast Kelly read FEAR STREET NIGHTS: MOONLIGHT SECRETS, MIDNIGHT GAMES, and DARKEST DAWN by R.L. Stine and Lindsay read Moonlight Secrets. They talk misguided naming paradigms, evil crows, loser bartenders, extreme lip violence, and more!
KELLY WROTE A BOOK! Order THE LATCHKEY TWINS Case No. 46: The Twins Solve a Murder here!
Help us out by taking an ads survey!
SUBSCRIBE ON PATREON for ad free and video eps, bonus eps, & more.
TEEN CREEPS IS AN INDEPENDENT PODCAST.
*All creepy opinions expressed are those of the hosts and guests.
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Teen Creeps Ratings
Overall
Overall rating of the media
Atmosphere
How immersive and tense is the atmosphere
Story
Quality of the storyline and plot
Production Quality
Overall production value
Sound Design
Audio quality and sound effects
Entertainment Value
How entertaining is it
Educational Value
Learning and informational value