Sunday Shadows: 9-11 Nightmare / Unseen Depths
Released on 05/24/2026
I'm Anna Dark. Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read to you scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
Today's stories: Â
 9-11 Nightmare / Unseen Depths from Dawn Kaye
 If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Anna      Â
Friday Night Frights: I Got A Letter on My Office Desk That I Shouldn't Have Read
Released on 05/21/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
I Got A Letter on My Office Desk That I Shouldn't Have Read — From Steven Furness. Read by Robert Hessenburg.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Episode 247: I Blew Up My Own Fishing Boat. Tomorrow, I’m Lying to the Police About Why / Dem Bloody Fishermen
Released on 05/20/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
I Blew Up My Own Fishing Boat. Tomorrow, I’m Lying to the Police About Why — From Fred Geller. Read by Robert Hessenburg.
Dem Bloody Fishermen — From Gary D.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Throwback Thursday: The Ouija Board Spirit Children
Released on 05/20/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
Today's stories: Â The Ouija Board Spirit Children from u/ItsOk_ItsAlright
The Old Man in the Closet from u/Gold_Introduction747
Was she trying to burn us alive? from u/bobbybrown666420
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Anna
Episode 246: I’m a Psychiatrist. My Patients Describe the Same Man in Their Dreams.
Released on 05/19/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
I’m a Psychiatrist. My Patients Describe the Same Man in Their Dreams. — From Dora Richardson.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Monday Chiller: My Sleep App Keeps Recording Conversations I Don’t Remember Having
Released on 05/18/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
My Sleep App Keeps Recording Conversations I Don’t Remember Having — From Lynn Woods. Read by Melanie Craven.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Sunday Shadows: Every Night at 3AM, Something Tried to Pull Me Out of Bed / Titanic Ghosts
Released on 05/17/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
Every Night at 3AM, Something Tried to Pull Me Out of Bed — From Amanda Spivey.
Titanic Ghosts — From Gary D.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Friday Night Frights: There’s a Door in My Apartment Building That Only Appears After Midnight
Released on 05/15/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
There’s a Door in My Apartment Building That Only Appears After Midnight — From Coleen Sanders. Read by Kirsty Strazinski.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Throwback Thursday: The Man at my Bedroom Window
Released on 05/14/2026
I'm Anna Dark. Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read to you scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
Today's stories: Â
The Man at my Bedroom Window and The Grey Lady from Natalie Young Â
Cherry Pie by Gary D
Who was Daniel Wamsel? From Russ
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Anna      Â
Episode 245: Four Days Into a Blizzard, Something Knocked on My Cabin Door.
Released on 05/13/2026
I'm Anna Dark.
Welcome to 'Let Me Tell You A Scary Story,' a podcast where I read scary true-life stories from ordinary people.
If you want an ad free experience, with bonus episodes every week, please join our Patreon:
https://www.patreon.com/cw/LetmetellyouaScaryStory
Four Days Into a Blizzard, Something Knocked on My Cabin Door — From Hailey Devon. Read by Kirsty Strazinski.
If you have a true story of something scary that happened to you and you would like me to read it out on the show, then please send it to me at [email protected]
Sleep Tight
Let me tell you a Scary Story Ratings
Overall
Overall rating of the media
Atmosphere
How immersive and tense is the atmosphere
Story
Quality of the storyline and plot
Production Quality
Overall production value
Sound Design
Audio quality and sound effects
Entertainment Value
How entertaining is it
Educational Value
Learning and informational value